Department of Health and Human Services
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS BOARD
Civil Remedies Division
Sudipta Mazumder,
(NPI: 1467560805) (PTANs: 2057615E, 2057615G, 6057615H, PVM0690)
Petitioner,
v.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Docket No. C-22-557
Decision No. CR7019
DECISION
Petitioner, Sudipta Mazumder, is a physician, who was enrolled in the Medicare program as a supplier of services, practicing in North Carolina. Because she was unable to produce patient medical records that a Medicare program integrity contractor requested, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) revoked her Medicare billing privileges pursuant to 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(10) and imposed a ten-year reenrollment bar.
Petitioner now appeals.
I affirm CMS’s determination. I find that CMS is authorized to revoke Petitioner’s Medicare privileges because she ordered durable medical equipment for patients but did not maintain medical records for those patients and could not supply those records when the program integrity contractor requested them. I have no authority to review the length of the reenrollment bar.
Background
In a letter dated September 8, 2020, the Medicare contractor, Palmetto GBA, advised Petitioner that her Medicare privileges were revoked, effective October 8, 2020.
Page 2
The letter explained that the contractor revoked Petitioner’s Medicare privileges pursuant to 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(10), because, when asked to do so, she did not provide, to SafeGuard Services, LLC, the program integrity contractor, medical records for Medicare beneficiaries for whom she had ordered DMEPOS (durable medical equipment, prosthetics, orthotics, and supplies). Failing to provide access to the requested documentation violates 42 C.F.R. § 424.516(f). CMS Ex. 5. The contractor imposed a ten-year reenrollment bar, pursuant to 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(c). Id.
Petitioner requested reconsideration. CMS Ex. 6. In a reconsidered determination, dated March 31, 2022, a CMS hearing officer upheld the revocation. CMS Ex. 1.
Petitioner timely appealed.
On October 22, 2024, the parties filed a joint motion to stay while Petitioner’s appeal and sentencing in her criminal case was pending. The stay was granted and the parties were ordered to file continuing status reports.
On June 9, 2026, Petitioner filed a notice indicating that Petitioner’s appeals had concluded and the stay was lifted on June 16, 2026.
Decision based on the written record. On September 27, 2024, Administrative Law Judge Jacinta Alves1 denied the parties’ motions for summary judgment. However, this matter may be decided based on the written record. CMS proposes no witnesses. Petitioner proposes one witness (herself) and has submitted her written declaration (P. Ex. 1). See January 22, 2026 Order re Cross Examination. The order directed CMS to indicate, affirmatively, that it wanted to cross-examine a witness. CMS timely responded and indicated that it did not want to cross-examine Petitioner. Because there are no witnesses to be examined further or cross-examined, an in-person hearing would serve no purpose, and I may decide this case based on the written record.2
Exhibits. Prior to the stay, CMS submitted a motion for summary judgment and brief (CMS Br.) with eleven exhibits (CMS Exs. 1-11). Petitioner submitted her brief and own motion for summary judgment (P. Br.) with two exhibits (P. Exs. 1-2). As indicated above, the motions for summary judgment were denied.
Page 3
Following the end of the stay, CMS filed a supplemental brief and submitted seven additional exhibits (CMS Exs. 12-18). Petitioner filed her own supplemental brief but did not submit any additional exhibits.
Previously, the parities’ exhibits were admitted into evidence. In the absence of any objections, I also admit into evidence CMS Exs. 12-18.
Discussion
The Medicare Program. The Medicare program, Title XVIII of the Social Security Act (Act), is a federally-subsidized insurance program that provides health care benefits to the elderly, disabled, and those suffering from end stage renal disease. Medicare is divided into four parts:
- Part A is the hospital insurance program. It covers hospital services, post-hospital extended care, home health, and hospice care. Act § 1811 (42 U.S.C. § 1395c);
- Part B, which is voluntary, is the supplementary medical insurance program, covering physician, home health, hospice, and other services. Act § 1832 (42 U.S.C. § 1395k);
- Part C is the Medicare Advantage program, which allows its participants to enroll in “Medicare + Choice” plans, managed by organizations, such as health maintenance organizations, that receive a fixed payment for each enrollee. Act § 1851 (42 U.S.C. § 1395w-21); and
- Part D is the voluntary prescription drug benefit program. Act § 1860D (42 U.S.C. § 1395w-101).
The Medicare program is administered by CMS, acting on behalf of the Secretary of Health and Human Services. CMS regulates the Medicare enrollment of providers and suppliers. Act § 1866(j)(1)(A) (42 U.S.C. § 1395cc(j)(1)(A)). Physicians and other practitioners (such as Petitioner) may participate in the program as “suppliers” of services. Act §§ 1861(d), (s)(2)(H),(K) (42 U.S.C. §§ 1395x(d), (s)(2)(H), (K)); 42 C.F.R. § 400.202.
CMS contracts with Medicare administrative contractors, who process and pay reimbursement claims and perform other duties necessary to carry out program purposes. Act § 1842 (42 U.S.C. § 1395u). Contractors pay claims to “providers” (Part A) and “suppliers” (Part B).
Page 4
1. CMS may revoke Petitioner’s Medicare enrollment, pursuant to 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(10), because she ordered DMEPOS items for Medicare beneficiaries but did not maintain documentation relating to those orders and, when the Medicare program integrity contractor asked her to provide that documentation, she would not or could not produce it, which violates 42 C.F.R. § 424.516(f).3
Revocation of enrollment. The Medicare statute authorizes the Secretary of Health and Human Services to revoke a supplier’s Medicare enrollment (for a period of not more than one year for each act) if the supplier does not maintain, and, upon request, provide access to documentation relating to written orders or requests for payment for durable medical equipment or other items or services written or ordered by the supplier. Act § 1842(h)(9). Implementing the statutory provisions, CMS’s regulations provide that CMS, acting on behalf of the Secretary, may revoke a supplier’s Medicare enrollment if she doesn’t comply with the documentation or access requirements of 42 C.F.R. § 424.516(f). 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(10).
Section 424.516(f)(2)(i) provides that a physician or an “eligible professional” who orders DMEPOS items must maintain documentation of the transactions for seven years. “Documentation” includes written and electronic documents, including the NPI (national provider identifier) of the physician or eligible professional, relating to written orders and certifications and requests for payment for items of DMEPOS. 42 C.F.R. § 424.516(f).
Petitioner’s noncompliance with the documentation and access requirements of section 424.516(f). Petitioner is a physician, who was licensed and practicing in North Carolina. P. Ex. 1; CMS Ex. 1.
In a letter dated February 5, 2020, SafeGuard advised Petitioner that it was reviewing certain claims submitted to Medicare for durable medical equipment supplies for which she was listed as the ordering physician. CMS Ex. 2. The letter then listed 20 Medicare beneficiaries, with identifying information, and asked Petitioner to produce their medical records within 45 days of the letters’ postmark dates. CMS Ex. 2. The letter warned that failing to comply with the requests could result in Petitioner’s exclusion from participation in the Medicare program. Id.
Receiving no response, on July 15, 2020, SafeGuard sent a follow-up letter, advising Petitioner that it had not received a response to its February 5, 2020 request for medical documentation. The letter warned that, if it did not receive the medical records within 15
Page 5
days from the date of the letter, “administrative action, including revocation, may be taken.” CMS Ex. 4.
SafeGuard sent both of these letters to the correspondence addresses on file for Petitioner, although Petitioner argues that she did not receive them. CMS Exs. 2, 4; P. Ex. 1. The letters from SafeGuard were sent to the correspondence and mailing address provided by Petitioner in her PECOS enrollment file. CMS Exs. 2-4.
Petitioner failed to respond to either of SafeGuard’s letters requesting the documentation she was required to maintain. Additionally, CMS gave Petitioner an additional opportunity to produce the requested records when it communicated with her attorney at the time. CMS Ex. 7. Nothing in Petitioner’s declaration disputes the fact that she did not maintain the required documentation. P. Ex. 1. CMS is therefore authorized to revoke her Medicare enrollment. Act § 1842(h)(9)); 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(10); George M. Young, M.D., DAB No. 2750 at 8 (2016).
Petitioner argues that her employers used her NPI without her knowledge and that she was not responsible for ordering the DMEPOS items. P. Ex. 1; P. Br. However; Petitioner does not provide any evidence to support this assertion. CMS provided medical documents and signed written orders related to the beneficiaries listed on the medical records request. Documents utilized during the criminal proceedings show that Petitioner signed detailed written orders and other medical documentation for at least seven of the twenty beneficiaries. CMS Ex. 17. CMS submitted exhibits that show that Petitioner signed similar documents for at least six of the other beneficiaries listed on the February 5, 2020 medical record request. Id. Petitioner provides no evidence to support her contention that her employers used her NPI without her knowledge to submit orders for DMEPOS items.
Petitioner also argues that there is confusion between failing to maintain records and failing to produce the records. However, such an argument is without merit. SafeGuard requested the records from Petitioner on three separate occasions and on three separate occasions, Petitioner failed to produce the records. Section 424.516(f)(2)(i) provides that a physician or an “eligible professional” who orders DMEPOS items must maintain documentation of the transactions for seven years. “Documentation” includes written and electronic documents, including the NPI (national provider identifier) of the physician or other eligible professional, relating to written orders, certifications and requests for payment for items of DMEPOS. 42 C.F.R. § 424.516(f)((1)(ii). Petitioner did not produce the records as requested or otherwise show that she maintained any records.
Petitioner also argues that CMS cannot now cite as a basis for her revocation the North Carolina Medical Board’s consent order dated June 25, 2026 indefinitely suspending Petitioner’s medical license. However, as discussed above, I find that CMS had authority
Page 6
to revoke Petitioner’s billing privileges under section 424.535(a)(10) and so additional discussion regarding 42 C.F.R. § 424.510 is unnecessary.
The Departmental Appeals Board has consistently held that an administrative law judge’s review of CMS’s determination to revoke a supplier’s Medicare enrollment is limited to deciding whether CMS has established one or more of the grounds specified in section 424.535(a). William Garner, M.D., DAB No. 3026 at 16 (2020); Norman Johnson, M.D., DAB No. 2779 at 11 (2017), and cases cited therein. Although CMS itself has the discretion to consider “unique or mitigating circumstances in deciding whether, or how, to exercise its revocation authority,” I do not. I may not substitute my discretion for that of CMS in determining whether the revocation is appropriate. Johnson at 11 (citing Care Pro Home Health, Inc., DAB No. 2723 at 9 n.8 (2016); Abdul Razzaque Ahmed, M.D., DAB No. 2261 at 19 (2009), aff’d, Ahmed v. Sebelius, 710 F. Supp. 2d 167 (D. Mass. 2010)).
Here, CMS plainly had the authority to revoke Petitioner’s Medicare enrollment under section 424.535(a)(10). Petitioner ordered DMEPOS items for Medicare beneficiaries but she did not maintain patient records and, when asked to do so, could not produce them. I must therefore affirm the revocation.
I have no authority to review Petitioner’s Constitutional claims. Blair Allen Nelson, M.D., DAB No. 3024 at 9-10 (2020).
2. I have no authority to review CMS’s determination to impose a ten-year reenrollment bar.
When a supplier’s billing privileges are revoked, she may not participate in the Medicare program until the end of her reenrollment bar, which must be for a minimum of one year but no more than ten years (except under circumstances that do not apply here), depending on the severity of the underlying offense. 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(c)(1). Here, CMS imposed a ten-year reenrollment bar. Petitioner argues that the ten-year reenrollment bar violates the regulation, which authorizes “revocation for a period of not more than 1 year for each act of noncompliance.” 42 C.F.R. § 424.535(a)(10)(ii). In Petitioner’s view, she committed, at most, one act of noncompliance. In fact, CMS has provided evidence for at least 13 such acts. Failing to produce any requested document violates section 424.516(f), and here Petitioner failed to do so for at least 13 times. See Young, DAB No. 2750 at 9 (suggesting that failing to produce any requested document violates section 424.516(f)).
In any event, I have no authority to review the length of the reenrollment bar. Vijendra Dave, M.D., DAB No. 2672 at 9-12 (2016); accord, Garner, DAB No. 3026 at 16; Lilia Gorovits, M.D., P.C., DAB No. 2985 at 15-16 (2020); see 42 C.F.R. § 498.3(b)(17).
Page 7
Conclusion
CMS has established grounds for revoking Petitioner Mazumder’s Medicare enrollment under section 424.535(a)(10): she did not comply with the documentation or access requirements of section 424.516(f). I have no authority to review the reenrollment bar imposed.
I therefore affirm CMS’s determination.
Kourtney LeBlanc Administrative Law Judge
- 1This case was transferred to me on January 21, 2026.
- 2That I decide this case based on the written record does not mean that Petitioner has not had a hearing. Courts recognize that, although a case may be decided on summary judgment or based on the written record, the administrative law judge, by considering the evidence and applying the law, has granted the petitioner a hearing. See CNG Transmission Corp. v. FERC, 40 F.3d 1289, 1293 (D.C. Cir. 1994) (holding that a “paper hearing” satisfies statutory requirements for “notice and opportunity for hearing.”).
- 3My findings of fact/conclusions of law are set forth, in italics and bold, in the discussion captions of this decision.