Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Here’s how you know

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

HTTPS

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock (LockA locked padlock) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Freedom 250 banner logo Join HHS in Celebrating Freedom 250
    • About HHS

      HHS is a U.S. executive department that touches the lives of nearly all Americans by protecting your rights, research, food safety, health care, aging, and much more.

    • Explore About HHS
    • About the Department
      • Leadership
      • HHS Divisions
      • Organizational Chart
      • Priorities
      • Budget in Brief
      • Contact Us
    • Press Room
      • Press Releases
      • Request for Comment
      • Request for Interview
      • Connect on Social Media
      • HHS Live
      • Podcasts
    • Careers
      • Working at HHS
      • Opportunities for Attorneys
      • Join the Health Workforce
      • I am HHS
      • New Employee Orientation
      • Transportation Services
    • Standards and Compliance
      • Gold Standard Science
      • Accessibility
      • Plain Writing
      • Digital Communications Standards
      • Records Management
    • Accountability and Transparency
      • Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)
      • Open Government
      • No Fear Act
      • Privacy at HHS
    • NUTRITION IN AMERICA

      HHS is advancing the Make America Healthy Again agenda by putting nutrition at the center of health. President Trump and Secretary Kennedy flipped the food pyramid to encourage Americans to Eat Real Food.

    • Explore Nutrition in America
    • Advancing Nutrition Education
    • Make Hospital Food Healthy Again
    • Eat Real Food
    • The Real Food Show
  • MAHA
    • Programs & Services

      HHS is responsible for public health, health care, and human/social services for the United States of America. This includes administering over 100 programs and services.

    • Explore Programs & Services
    • Health Care
      • Find a Health Center
      • Find an Indian Health Service Facility
      • Find Support for Mental Health, Drugs, or Alcohol
      • Find a Cancer Center
      • Dental Care Options
      • Telehealth
    • Health Insurance
      • Medicare – 65+ or With Disability
      • Medicaid - Low-Income, With Disability, or Pregnant
      • Children’s Health Insurance Programs (CHIP)
      • Find Health Insurance Coverage
      • Insurance Help for Mental Health and Substance Use
      • No Surprise Medicals Bills
    • Social Services
      • Programs for Children and Families
      • Programs for People with Disabilities
      • Programs for Older Adults
      • Resources for Caregivers
    • Public Health and Prevention
      • Emergency Preparedness and Response
      • Healthy Lifestyle
      • Mental Health and Substance Use
      • Food Safety and Nutrition
      • Drug and Product Safety
    • Health Research and Information
      • National Library of Medicine
      • Surgeon General Reports
      • Health Data
      • National Center for Health Statistics
      • Medline Plus
      • Clinical Research Studies
      • Volunteering to Participate in Research
    • Laws & Regulations

      HHS protects and helps you understand the laws and regulations, also known as "rules," that govern the nation. You also have the power to voice your opinion on these laws and regulations.

    • Explore Laws & Regulations
    • Regulatory Information
      • What is a Rule?
      • Find Rules by Division
      • Comment on Open Rules
      • Suggest Deregulatory Actions
      • Understand Key Federal Laws
    • Civil Rights
      • Your Civil Rights
      • Civil Rights Laws Enforced by HHS
      • Health Information Privacy
      • Substance Use Disorder Patient Confidentiality
      • Conscience and Religious Freedom
    • Laws and Regulations by Topic
      • HIPAA Privacy Rule
      • Health Insurance Protections
      • Health IT Legislation
      • Food and Drug Safety
      • Public Health Emergencies
    • Human Research Protections
      • The Belmont Report
      • Regulations, Policy, and Guidance
      • Human Subjects Regulations (45 CFR 46)
      • Register IRBs and Obtain FWAs
      • Trainings, Tutorials, and Workshops
      • International Research
    • Complaints and Appeals
      • File a Medicare Complaint
      • File a HIPAA Complaint
      • File a Civil Rights Complaint
      • Appeal an Insurance Company Decision
      • Report Fraud, Waste, and Abuse to OIG
      • Report a Problem to the FDA
      • Report a Tip on the Chemical and Surgical Mutilation of Children
    • Grants & Contracts

      HHS gives the most money in grants of any federal agency in the U.S. Find out about our grants and how your organization can apply for them. We also provide information on how you can work with us and our support of small businesses.

    • Explore Grants & Contracts
    • Grants
      • Get Ready for Grants Management
      • Grant Policies and Regulations
      • Research Grants and Funding from NIH
      • Search Grants.gov
      • Avoid Grant Scams
      • Contact HHS Grant Officials
    • Contracts
      • Get Ready to Do Business with HHS
      • Programs for Businesses
      • Contract Policies and Regulations
      • Search Opportunities on SAM.gov
      • Contact HHS Contracting Managers
    • Small Business
      • Contract Opportunities
      • Small Business Programs
      • Small Business Resources
      • Contact Small Business Staff
    • Radical Transparency

      HHS protects and helps you understand the laws and regulations, also known as "rules," that govern the nation. You also have the power to voice your opinion on these laws and regulations.

    • Explore Radical Transparency
    • CDC’s ACIP Conflicts of Interest
    • Ending Anti-Semitism on College Campuses
    • Ending Wasteful Spending
    • Keeping Food Ingredients Safe
    • Chemical Contaminants Transparency Tool
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. About HHS
  3. Agencies
  4. DAB
  5. Decisions
  6. ALJ Decision…
  7. 2026 ALJ Decisions
  8. Caribbean Cancer Care Services LLC, DAB CR7011 (2026)
  • Departmental Appeals Board (DAB)
  • About DAB
    • Organizational Overview
    • Who are the Judges?
    • DAB Divisions
    • Contact DAB
  • Filing an Appeal Online
    • DAB E-File
    • Medicare Operations Division (MOD) E-File
  • Different Appeals at DAB
    • Appeals to DAB Administrative Law Judges (ALJs)
      • Forms
      • Procedures
    • Appeals to Board
      • Practice Manual
      • Guidelines
      • Regulations
      • National Coverage Determination Complaints
    • Appeals to the Medicare Appeals Council (Council)
      • Forms
      • Fully Integrated Duals Advantage (FIDA) Demonstration Project
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution Services
    • Mediation
    • ADR Training
    • Other ADR Services
  • DAB Decisions
    • Board Decisions
    • DAB Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Decisions
    • Medicare Appeals Council (Council) Decisions
  • Stakeholder Feedback
  • Careers
    • Open Career Opportunities
    • Internships & Externships

Caribbean Cancer Care Services LLC, DAB CR7011 (2026)


Department of Health and Human Services
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS BOARD
Civil Remedies Division

Caribbean Cancer Care Services LLC, 
(PTAN: IB945A, NPI No.: 1679900567), 
Petitioner,

v.

Centers For Medicare & Medicaid Services.

Docket No. C-25-543
Decision No. CR7011
November 2, 2026

DECISION

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), through a Medicare administrative contractor, determined that the effective date for the reactivation of Medicare billing privileges for Caribbean Cancer Care Services LLC (CCCS or Petitioner) was October 11, 2024.  Petitioner requested a hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ) to challenge the effective date.  Because the administrative contractor approved CCCS’s revalidation enrollment application that was received on October 11, 2024, the earliest possible effective is October 11, 2024.  As explained below, I find that CMS properly determined October 11, 2024, as the effective date for Petitioner’s Medicare reactivation. 

I.  Background and Procedural History

Petitioner is a clinic/group practice with several practice locations in Puerto Rico.  CMS Exhibit (Ex.) 4 at 13, 17-28.  In March 2024, First Coast Service Options, Inc. (First Coast), a Medicare administrative contractor, notified CCCS that it was required to revalidate its Medicare enrollment record by June 30, 2024.  CMS Ex. 2.  The letter warned that, if the required information was not received, “we may stop your Medicare billing privileges” and a gap in reimbursement could result.  Id. at 1.  On July 3, 2024,

Page 2

First Coast notified CCCS that a stay was placed on its Medicare enrollment.  CMS Ex. 3.  The letter informed Petitioner that during the stay “claims for services and items you furnish during this period will be rejected.”  Id.  First Coast also explained that a failure to submit a revalidation application within 30 days of the letter could result in a deactivation and that deactivation would cause a gap in reimbursement.  Id. 

On July 24, 2024, Petitioner submitted a revalidation application.  CMS Ex. 4.  After submitting the application, CCCS received a development letter request from First Coast requesting revisions and/or documentation.  Specifically, the letter, dated August 22, 2024, requested the following: 

  • Please provide information for all Practice Locations in Section 4A of your application.
  • Please resubmit Section 6 with the information for all Owners and Managing Employees and include all active roles.
  • A new certification statement, Section 15,  must be signed and dated by an Authorized/Delegated official.
  • Please submit the request revisions and/or supporting documentation within 30 days . . . .

CMS Ex. 5 at 1.  On September 3, 2024, CCCS faxed its response to First Coast.  CMS Ex. 6. 

On September 27, 2024, First Coast sent Petitioner a letter notifying it that its Medicare billing privileges were being deactivated because Petitioner either did not timely revalidate its enrollment record or did not timely respond to requests for additional information.  CMS Ex. 7.  CCCS submitted a revalidation application on October 11, 2024.  CMS Ex. 8.  In response to this application, First Coast sent Petitioner another development letter request, dated November 4, 2024, requesting the following: 

  • Please correct section 6A for Rolando Jimenex to also show authorized official
  • Please sign and date new certification (section 15)
  • Please submt a CNS-588 (EFT)
  • Please submit a voided check or bank letter
  • Please submit a PAR agreement
  • Please submit the request revisions and/or supporting documentation within 30 days . . . .

CMS. Ex. 9 at 1.  In response to the development letter, Petitioner faxed a response on November 13, 2024.  CMS Ex. 10.  Petitioner submitted an additional response on December 9, 2024.  CMS Ex. 11.  Finally, on December 11, 2024, First Coast approved

Page 3

Petitioner’s reactivation enrollment application with a gap in billing privileges from September 27, 2024 through October 10, 2024.  CMS Ex. 12. 

Petitioner timely filed a request for reconsideration, arguing that it submitted the proper documentation during the revalidation cycle.  CMS Ex. 13.  On February 14, 2025, First Coast issued an unfavorable reconsidered determination.  CMS Ex. 14.  In the reconsidered determination, First Coast determined the reactivation effective date for CCCS to be October 11, 2024.  Id. at 4.  First Coast also corrected the start date for the gap in billing and changed it to July 1, 2024.  Id. at 3. 

Petitioner timely filed a request for hearing to challenge the reconsidered determination.  On April 14, 2025, the Civil Remedies Division (CRD) acknowledged receipt of the request for hearing and issued a Standing Prehearing Order (SPO).  In the SPO, the parties were directed to file a prehearing exchange and were permitted to file motions for summary judgment in lieu of or in addition to their exchanges.  SPO ¶ 7.  CMS filed a prehearing brief with an incorporated motion for summary judgment (CMS Br.) and fourteen exhibits (CMS Ex. 1-14).  Petitioner filed a prehearing exchange with an incorporated opposition to CMS’s motion for summary judgment.  (P. Br.)  Petitioner did not submit any exhibits.  CMS did not file a rebuttal or notice declining to file a rebuttal statement.  Finally, Petitioner filed an informative motion and request for adjudication explaining that settlement efforts were unsuccessful and that the case was “ripe for resolution.”  CRD Docket Entry No. 11 at 1. 

II.  Admission of Evidence and Decision on the Written Record

Petitioner did not object to any of CMS’s proposed exhibits.  I therefore admit CMS Exs. 1-14 into the record. 

The SPO advised the parties that an in-person hearing would only be held if a party submitted the written direct testimony of a proposed witness and the opposing party requested an opportunity to cross-examine a witness.  SPO ¶¶ 11-14; CRD Procedures §§ 16(b), 19(b); see Vandalia Park, DAB No. 1940 (2004); Pac. Regency Arvin, DAB No. 1823 at 8 (2002) (holding that the use of written direct testimony for witnesses is permissible so long as the opposing party has the opportunity to cross-examine those witnesses). 

Neither party has submitted written direct testimony.  Therefore, an in-person hearing is not required.  SPO ¶ 14; CRD Procedures § 19(d).  There is also no need for me to address the legal criteria for summary judgment; I find that this case is ripe for adjudication based on the written record. 

Page 4

III.  Issue

Whether CMS had a legitimate basis to assign October 11, 2024, as the effective date for reactivation of Petitioner’s Medicare billing privileges. 

IV.  Jurisdiction

I have jurisdiction to hear and decide this case.  42 C.F.R. § 498.3(b)(15). 

V.  Applicable Legal Authority

The Social Security Act (Act) authorizes the Secretary of Health and Human Services (Secretary) to promulgate regulations governing the enrollment process for providers and suppliers.  42 U.S.C. §§ 1302, 1395cc(j).  A “supplier” is “a physician or other practitioner, a facility, or other entity (other than a provider of services) that furnishes items or services” under the Medicare provisions of the Act.  42 U.S.C. § 1395x(d); see also 42 U.S.C. § 1395x(u). 

Petitioner, a supplier in the Medicare program, was required to enroll to receive payment for covered Medicare items or services.  42 C.F.R. § 424.505.  A provider or supplier seeking billing privileges under the Medicare program must “submit enrollment information on the applicable enrollment application.  Once the provider or supplier successfully completes the enrollment process . . . CMS enrolls the provider or supplier into the Medicare program.”  42 C.F.R. § 424.510(a).  CMS then establishes an effective date for billing privileges under the requirements stated in 42 C.F.R. § 424.520(d) and may allow limited retrospective billing under 42 C.F.R. § 424.521. 

After the initial enrollment, providers and suppliers must revalidate their enrollment information at least every five years to maintain Medicare billing privileges.  42 C.F.R. § 424.515.  However, CMS reserves the right to require revalidation at any time.  Id.  Upon notification from CMS that it is time to revalidate, providers and suppliers must submit the appropriate enrollment application, accurate information, and supporting documents within 60 calendar days of CMS’s notification.  42 C.F.R. § 424.515(a)(2). 

CMS can deactivate an enrolled provider’s or supplier’s Medicare billing privileges if the enrollee fails to comply with revalidation requirements.  42 C.F.R. § 424.540(a)(3).  When CMS deactivates a provider’s or supplier’s Medicare billing privileges, “[n]o payment may be made for otherwise Medicare covered items or services furnished to a Medicare beneficiary . . . .”  42 C.F.R. § 424.555(b).  If CMS deactivates a provider or supplier’s billing privileges due to an untimely response to a revalidation request, the enrolled provider or supplier may reactivate its Medicare billing privileges by recertifying that its enrollment information currently on file is correct, furnish any missing information, and comply with all applicable enrollment requirements.  42 C.F.R.

Page 5

§ 424.540(b)(1).  CMS may require that a deactivated provider or supplier submit a complete enrollment application.  42 C.F.R. § 424.540(b)(2). 

The effective date of a reactivation of billing privileges, following a period of deactivation, is the date on which the Medicare contractor received the supplier’s reactivation submission that was processed to approval.  42 C.F.R. § 424.540(d)(2). 

The determination of a supplier’s effective date is an “initial determination” subject to administrative review under 42 C.F.R. Part 498.  A supplier has no right to administrative review of a contractor’s decision to reject an enrollment application under section 424.525(a).  42 C.F.R. § 424.525(d); Wilson Radiological Medical Group, Inc., DAB No. 2941 (2019). 

VI.  Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Analysis

A.  On October 11, 2024, First Coast received Petitioner’s application for revalidation, which it processed to approval.1 

First Coast received Petitioner’s revalidation and reactivation application on October 11, 2024.  CMS Ex. 8.  Subsequently, First Coast approved CCCS’s application and reactivated its Medicare billing privileges, effective, October 11, 2024.  CMS Ex. 12. 

B.  The effective date for Petitioner’s Medicare billing privileges is October 11, 2024. 

In the instant case, First Coast properly determined that CCCS’s effective date for reactivation of its Medicare billing privileges is October 11, 2024, because that is the date First Coast received CCCS’s revalidation application that First Coast ultimately approved.  Therefore, pursuant to 42 C.F.R. § 424.540(d)(2), the date First Coast received Petitioner’s subsequently approved application, October 11, 2024, is the correct reactivation effective date of enrollment. 

C.  I do not have the authority to review the rejection of Petitioner’s prior application or the deactivation of Petitioner’s billing privileges. 

Petitioner asserts that the application submitted on October 11, 2024, was previously submitted on July 25, 2024 and September 3, 2024.  P. Br. at 7.  Petitioner argues that these application submissions, should have been processed to approval, thus resulting in an earlier effective date.  Id. 

Page 6

The record reflects that CCCS submitted an application on July 25, 2024.  CMS Ex. 4.  CCCS then submitted a response to a development letter received on August 22, 2024.  CMS Ex. 6.  Unfortunately, First Coast did not approve the application even after Petitioner submitted a response to the development letter requesting more information and revisions.  First Coast deactivated CCCS’s billing privileges, effective September 27, 2024. 

Petitioner’s request to seek an earlier effective date based on the rejected application is, in essence, a request for administrative review of First Coast’s decision to reject the application.  The rejection of its application does not afford Petitioner appeal rights, and I do not have the authority to review First Coast’s decision.  42 C.F.R. § 424.525(d); Wilson Radiological Medical Group, Inc., DAB No. 2941 (2019).  Unfortunately, because the application that was submitted in July 2024 was not subsequently approved, the correct effective date is October 11, 2024, because that is the date that the application that was subsequently approved was submitted.  Petitioner argues that the applications are identical and that its deactivation was an error because it supplied all the required additional information requested.  P. Br. at 2.  The evidence shows that the applications were, in fact, not completely identical and some information was incomplete in the earlier application and not corrected in Petitioner’s development response.  For example, the July application and August response to the development letter do not show Dr. Rolando Jimenez as an authorized official.  CMS Ex. 6 at 21; CMS Ex. 4 at  36.  In the development responses submitted by Petitioner after the October application, Dr. Jimenez is listed as an authorized official.  CMS Ex. 10 at 9; CMS Ex. 11 at 81.  Additionally, section 4 of the application for practice location information is different in the later submitted application and includes an additional location.  CMS. Ex. 8 at 35.  However, even if the applications were identical, I may not exceed my authority and review the rejection of the earlier application. 

Petitioner expresses dissatisfaction with the lack of specificity in the deactivation letter.  P. Br. at 9.  To the extent that Petitioner contests the deactivation, this argument is immaterial because I do not have the authority to review whether deactivation was proper.  Jeffrey E. McIlroy, MD, Inc., DAB No. 3143 at 3-4 (2024); Tosan Fregene, M.D. & Oncology Clinics, Inc., DAB No. 3018 at 3 (2020); see 42 C.F.R. § 498.3(b) (defining “initial determinations” that are subject to review by an ALJ and the Departmental Appeals Board); 42 C.F.R. §§ 424.540(e), 424.555(b).  Deactivation is not an initial determination, and deactivation decisions have a separate review process involving the submission of a rebuttal to CMS.  See 42 C.F.R. §§ 424.545(b), 498.3(b); see also Willie Goffney, Jr., M.D., DAB No. 2763 at 4-5 (2017). 

Finally, to the extent that Petitioner requests equitable relief, I do not have the authority to grant it. US Ultrasound, DAB No. 2302 at 8 (2010).  Unfortunately, I do not have the authority to grant an earlier effective date based on equitable or policy arguments.  Howard M. Sokoloff, DPM, MS, Inc., DAB No. 2972 at 6, 9 (2019); Wishon Radiological

Page 7

Med. Grp., Inc., DAB No. 2941 at 6-7 (2019); Ark. Health Grp., DAB No. 2929 at 7-9 (2019); James Shepard, M.D., DAB No. 2793 at 8 (2017). 

VII.  Conclusion

Because the Medicare administrative contractor received Petitioner’s revalidation application on October 11, 2024, and later processed that application to approval, that is the effective date of Petitioner’s Medicare enrollment and billing privileges.  I may not review the Medicare administrative contractor’s rejection of Petitioner’s earlier application.  Therefore, I affirm CMS’s determination. 

/s/

Marla Y. Johnson Administrative Law Judge

  • 1My findings of fact and conclusions of law appear as headings in bold italic type.
Back to top
Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

Follow @SecKennedy

HHS icon

Follow @HHSGov

HHS Email updates

Receive email updates from HHS.

Subscribe

HHS Logo

HHS Headquarters

200 Independence Avenue, S.W.
Washington, D.C. 20201
Toll Free Call Center: 1-877-696-6775​

  • Contact HHS
  • Careers
  • HHS FAQs
  • Nondiscrimination Notice
  • Press Room
  • HHS Archive
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Budget/Performance
  • Inspector General
  • Web Site Disclaimers
  • EEO/No Fear Act
  • FOIA
  • The White House
  • USA.gov
  • Vulnerability Disclosure Policy