Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Here’s how you know

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

HTTPS

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock (LockA locked padlock) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

  • About HHS
  • Programs & Services
  • Grants & Contracts
  • Laws & Regulations
  • Radical Transparency
  • Big Wins
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. About
  3. Agencies
  4. DAB
  5. Decisions
  6. ALJ Decisions
  7. 2012 ALJ Decisions
  • Departmental Appeals Board (DAB)
  • About DAB
    • Organizational Overview
    • Who are the Judges?
    • DAB Divisions
    • Contact DAB
  • Filing an Appeal Online
    • DAB E-File
    • Medicare Operations Division (MOD) E-File
  • Different Appeals at DAB
    • Appeals to DAB Administrative Law Judges (ALJs)
      • Forms
      • Procedures
    • Appeals to Board
      • Practice Manual
      • Guidelines
      • Regulations
      • National Coverage Determination Complaints
    • Appeals to the Medicare Appeals Council (Council)
      • Forms
      • Fully Integrated Duals Advantage (FIDA) Demonstration Project
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution Services
    • Sharing Neutrals, links to an external website
    • ADR Training
    • Other ADR Services
  • DAB Decisions
    • Board Decisions
    • DAB Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Decisions
    • Medicare Appeals Council (Council) Decisions
  • Stakeholder Feedback
  • Careers
    • Open Career Opportunities
    • Internships & Externships

2012 ALJ Decisions

Documents in PDF format require the Adobe Acrobat Reader®, links to an external website, opens in a new tab. If you experience problems with PDF documents, please download the latest version of the Reader®, links to an external website, opens in a new tab

2012.12.27 CR2678 Center for Tobacco Products v. Smith's Food and Drug Centers Inc. d/b/a/ Fry's Marketplace, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.12.21 CR2677 James Harrison Straub, Ed.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.12.13 CR2675 Primary Care Redmond, PLLC v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.12.13. ALJ Ruling 2013-2 Willow Tree Nursing Center v. CMS , opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.30 CR2674 Arizona Medical Boutique, LLC v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.30 CR2673 Social Security Administration, Inspector General v. Bruce Patton, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.27 CR2672 Bryan James Krajicek, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.26 CR2671 Wolverine State Inpatient Services v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.21 CR2670 Robert M. Barbati, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.21 CR2669 Spine Physicians Institute, P.A. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.20 CR2668 Shirlene Reese Boone v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.21 CR2667 Lori Rae Johanesen-McEwen v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.19 CR2666 Laurie S. Coyner, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.19 ALJ Ruling 2013-1; CTP v. Ralph Baskerville d/b/a 4744 Corner Store, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.16 CR2665 Qualicare Nursing Home v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.09 CR2660 Glenoaks Nursing Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.09 CR2664 In re CMS LCD Complain LCD L29288, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.09 CR2663 In re CMS LCD Complain Category III CPT Codes (L25275), opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.09 CR2662 In re CMS LCD Complaint Noncovered Services (LCD L29288), opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.08 CR2661 Arnon Graham v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.07 CR2659 In re LCD Complaint External Infusion Pumps (LCD ID No. L11570), opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.06 CR2658 Trinity Hill Care Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.11.05 CR2657 Deltona Health Care v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.31 CR2656 In re CMS LCD Complaint: Posterior Tibial Nerve Stimulation PTNS (L28457), opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.25 CR2655 Wildcreek Healthcare, Inc. d/b/a Rosewood Rehabilitation Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.24 CR2653 Springhill Senior Residence v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.19 CR2652 Center for Tobacco Products v. Francisco Taveras and David Moya d/b/a South Broadway Market, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.17 CR2650 Haissam Elzaim, M.D., Southern Texas Physician Network, HSE Orthopaedic Surgery Clinic v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.17 CR2649 Center for Tobacco Products v. Lambert Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Lamberts Marathon #3, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.17 CR2648 Bellmore Medical PLLC v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.16 CR2647 Social Security Administration v. James M. Nicolaw, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.15 CR2646 Mary C. Manesis, DPM, PA v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.15 CR2645 Jason Elliott Evans v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.15 CR2644 Center for Tobacco Products v. Big Bear Tobacco, Inc. d/b/a Smokers Choice Smoke Shop, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.12 CR2643 Caratel Inns of Brighton v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.05 CR2642 Lake County Nursing & Rehabilitation Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.05 CR2640 Paul L. Daniels, Psy. D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.04 CR2639 Center for Tobacco Products v. Lil Mart, Inc., opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.03 CR2637 LaVaughn Caradine v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.02 CR2636 Center for Tobacco Products v. Ralph Baskerville d/b/a 4744 Corner Store, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.10.02 CR2635 Community Medical Lab, LLC v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.28 CR2634 Golden Living Center - Trussville v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.28 CR2633 Gursheel S. Dhillon, M.D. v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.28 CR2632 Karcher Estates v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.28 CR2631 Steve McFarland, ACNP v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.28 CR2629 CTP v. PS Investments, LLC d/b/a Air Park BP, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.28 CR2628 Better Sunrise Corporation v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.28 CR2627 The Orthotic Center, Inc. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.27 CR2625 Golden Living Center - Foley v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.21 CR2623 Center for Tobacco Products v. Falin Zhang d/b/a Happy House, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.21 CR2621 Center for Tobacco Products v. James Kenneth Lee d/b/a The Billiard Center, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.21 CR2620 Nostrand Rx Corp. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.20 CR2619 CTP v. C.Y.J. Inc. d/b/a Arco AM/PM 82832, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.19 CR2618 Center for Tobacco Products v. Retail Investments Incorporated d/b/a Shell Finish Line #14, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.19 CR2617 Hanover Hill Health Care Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.18 CR2616 Center for Tobacco Products v. Juan Martinez d/b/a Gratz Food Market, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.18 CR2614 Mercedes Children's Clinic/Mercedes Kids Med v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.31 CR2606 Center for Tobacco Products v. Larray Corporation d/b/a Jack's Market, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.31 CR2605 Center for Tobacco Products v. Jean Gervais d/b/a Papi's Mini Market, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.31 CR2604 Center for Tobacco Products v. Pamela Antonetty d/b/a Bodega, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.31 CR2603 Center for Tobacco Products v. Pastor Ledesma d/b/a El Ruvio Grocery and/or Antonia's Groceries, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.24 CR2602 Center for Tobacco Products v. Jing Sheng Liu d/b/a New China, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.24 CR2601 Center for Tobacco Products v. Mansort Srang d/b/a/ Girard Donut, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.09.13 CR2600 Covington Court Health and Rehabilitation Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.23 ALJ RUL 2012-3 Center for Tobacco Products v. Chambers Drive, Inc. d/b/a/ Dynasty Deli Quick Stop, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.22 CR2599 Center for Day Surgery v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.22 CR2598 Center for Tobacco Products v. Jario Estevez d/b/a Papi's Grocery, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.22 CR2597 Center for Tobacco Products v. Philip Yokwe d/b/a Jumbo Express, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.17 CR2595 Center for Tobacco Products v. Manuel Rodriguez, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.17 CR2594 Center for Tobacco Products v. Manuel A.Fernandez, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.17 CR2593 Center for Tobacco Products v. J & H of Washington, Inc., opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.17 CR2592 Senior Care Beltline v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.16 CR2591 Center for Tobacco Products v. KSD Petroleum, LLC, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.15 CR2590 Center for Tobacco Products v. Bi Xia Zhang, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.15 CR2589 Benefits Extended Care Center, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.17 CR2588 Bono Home Health Care, LLC v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.13 CR2587 Embassy Health Care Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.15 CR2586 Center for Tobacco Products v. OM SAI Krishna, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.13 ALJ RUL 2012-2 Todd Rider, Ph. D. v. Office of Research Integrity, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.10 CR2585 Royal Suites Health Care and Rehabilitation v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.08 CR2584 Florida Health Sciences Center, Inc. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.08 CR2583 Center for Tobacco Products v. Prater Holdings I, LLC, opens in a new tab [PDF].
2012.08.08 CR2582 Parallel Parkway Emergency Physicians v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.02 CR2580 The General Counsel v. Agustin, M.D., opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.08.02 CR2579 Center for Tobacco Products v. Country Manor Properties, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.27 CR2578 Thomas, PA v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.27 CR2577 San Fernando Post Acute Hospital v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.27 CR2576 Evergreen Health & Rehab v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.26 CR2575 Center for Tobacco Products v. Espinal d/b/a Liberty Mini Market, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.27 CR2574 Columbus Nursing and Rehabilitation Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.27 CR2573 Center for Tobacco Products v. Zimmerman d/b/a Beverage Mart, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.24 CR2572 Oliver DDS v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.24 CR2571 Evans, CRNA v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.24 CR2570 Center for Tobaccos Products v. Vinas Food Market, Inc., opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.18 CR2569 Mound City Inpatient Services v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.17 ALJ RUL 2012-1 Douglas L. Clore v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.17 CR2568 Michelle Slone v. I.G., opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.13 CR2567 Jedetta Green, ANP v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.13 CR2566 Bernard Farzin, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.12 CR2565 Susan Ortelt, PT v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.10 CR2564 Eagle Eye DME, LLC v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF] 2012.07.02 CR2563 Joseph v. Leyva v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.07.02 CR2562 Macinga and Ward v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.29 CR2561 Ridgecrest Healthcare Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.26 CR2560 New England Urogynecology, P.C. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.22 CR2559 Illig v. HHS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.25 CR2558 Ultrasound & Radiology Specialist, Inc. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.20 CR2557 Center for Tobacco Products v. Harvey Davis and Patricia Davis d/b/a Greenfield Trading Post, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.19 CR2556 Francis J. Gerner, Ph.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.19 CR2555 Alexander Eugene Istomin v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.18 CR2554 Ethan Edwin Bickelhaupt, M.D. v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.15 CR2553 Krish Venoo, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.15 CR2552 Michael K. Nunn, D.O. v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.29 CR2551 Linda Staiger, M.D., P.C. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.11 CR2550 CTP v. NTSC, LLC d/b/a Rookies Sports Bar & Grill, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.11 CR2549 CTP v. Pramukh Corporation d/b/a 7-Eleven #24057, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.11 CR2548 CTP v. DAL LLC d/b/a Spuds Bar & Grill, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.06.11 CR2547 Michael Reiner, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.31 CR2546 Pleasant View Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.15 CR2544 Four Seasons Nursing Center of Westland v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.15 CR2543 Center for Tobacco Products v. Broadway Citgo, Inc , opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.15 CR2542 Center for Tobacco Products v. Mohammad Farhan, d/b/a Gas Express, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.14 CR2541 Scott Harkonen, M.D. v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]  
2012.05.04 CR2540 Anirruddh v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.09 CR2539 Joseph Ravid, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.04 CR2538 Joshua J. Crabtree, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.04 CR2537 St. Anne's Convalescent Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.04 CR2536 Better Health Ambulance v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.04 CR2535 Timothy P. Ceynowa, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.03 CR2534 Diane Kennedy, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.03 CR2533 Eileen M. Rice, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.05.01 CR2532 In re CMS LCD Complaint: Services that are not Reasonable and Necessary, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.04.24 CR2531 Enitan Osagie Isiwele v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.04.20 CR2530 Lake Cook Terrace Nursing Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.04.19 CR2529 Anthony Lynn Hester v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.04.16 CR2528 Dawn Sea Kahrs, DC v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.04.16 CR2527 DeVille Pharmacies, Inc., d/b/a DeVille Medical Equipment and Oxygen v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.04.12 CR2526 Boone County Hospital v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.04.09 CR2525 Mabee Health Care Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.04.06 CR2524 Brett Sachse, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.04.03 CR2523 Bedford Care Center of Hattiesburg, LLC v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.30 CR2522 J.K. Optical, Inc. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.29 CR2521 Antonio Silva-Sayago, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.28 CR2520 Muhammad Bajwa v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.26 CR2519 Brad Carlson, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.22 CR2518 Buena Vista Care Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.20 CR2517 Ali S. Makki, M.D. v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.16 CR2516 Edward Alexander Birts v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.16 CR2515 Christopher George Collins v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.15 CR2514 Steven C. Wein v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.14 CR2513 Legacy Health and Rehabilitation Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.06 CR2512 Michael D. Miran, Esta Miran, and Michael D. Miran, Ph.D. Psychologist P.C. v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.03.28 CR2511 Sorrento Care Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.28 CR2510 Phyllis Barson, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.28 CR2509 Life Care Center of Bardstown v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.24 CR2508 Integrated Diagnostic of South Florida, Inc. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.24 CR2507 Raymond L. Bedell, D.O. v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.22 CR2506 Mountain Villa Nursing Center v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.22 CR2505 Tiffiney Shawn Bentley v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.22 CR2504 Golden Living Center – Colonial Manor v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.22 CR2503 Candace Lynn Reid v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.13 CR2502  Karen Karsif, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.13 CR2501 Bethany Anne Winther-Galimore and the Winther Family Chiropractic Center, LLC v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.10 CR2500 NBM Healthcare Inc. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.07 CR2499 Roshele Gene Barber v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.02.07 CR2498 Mariken Wogstad-Hansen, PhD, LP, RN, CNS v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.30 CR2497 Patricia Marie Meade vs. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.30 CR2496 Guy R. Seaton vs. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.27 CR2495 Jay Shankar Jha vs. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.25 CR2494 Hieu Trung Mai, D.D.S. vs. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.25 CR2493 Truc Trung Mai, D.D.S. vs. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.24 CR2492 Kids Med (Delta Medical Branch) v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.17 CR2491 Christine Dusenberry vs. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.17 CR2490 Huntington Beach Clinical Laboratory, Inc., Howard Pfupajena, M.D., Director v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.13 CR2489 Margally Samy v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.11 CR2488 Suitable Homehealth Care, Inc. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.11 CR2487 Edgar Narvaez v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.09 CR2486 Sonia Marie Rivera v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.09 CR2485 Charles S. Krin, D.O. v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.09 CR2484 Alexandra Shereshevskaya, M.D. v. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.06 CR2483 Edgard Cruz Baez, M.D. v. CMS, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.06 CR2482 Joby George vs. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.06 CR2481 Scott S. Reuben, M.D. vs. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]
2012.01.04 CR2480 Marcellius Jhekwuoba Anunobi vs. The Inspector General, opens in a new tab [PDF]

Content created by Departmental Appeals Board (DAB)
Content last reviewed October 6, 2016
Back to top

Subscribe to Email Updates

Receive the latest updates from the Secretary and Press Releases.

Subscribe
  • Contact HHS
  • Careers
  • HHS FAQs
  • Nondiscrimination Notice
  • Press Room
  • HHS Archive
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Budget/Performance
  • Inspector General
  • Web Site Disclaimers
  • EEO/No Fear Act
  • FOIA
  • The White House
  • USA.gov
  • Vulnerability Disclosure Policy
HHS Logo

HHS Headquarters

200 Independence Avenue, S.W.
Washington, D.C. 20201
Toll Free Call Center: 1-877-696-6775​

Follow HHS

Follow Secretary Kennedy