|
This is an archive page. The links are no longer being updated.
Performance and Accountability Report
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Asset Descriptions | Number of Sites | Total Square Footage | Federal Hectares | Total Hectares |
Heritage Assets |
3 |
3,429 |
2 (5 acres) |
2 (5 acres) |
Indian Trust Lands |
83 |
N/A |
442.8 (1,107 acres) |
442.8 (1,107acres) |
Distribution of Stewardship Assets by Type and Area
| Heritage Assets | Indian Trust Lands | ||||
|
Number of Sites |
Square Footage |
Total Hectares |
Number Of Sites |
Total Hectares |
Aberdeen |
|
|
|
9 |
75 |
Alaska |
2 |
1,134 |
2 |
|
|
Albuquerque |
|
|
|
4 |
4 |
Bemidji |
|
|
|
2 |
9 |
Billings |
|
|
|
7 |
48 |
Navajo |
|
|
|
34 |
256 |
Oklahoma City |
|
|
|
2 |
10 |
Phoenix |
1 |
2,295 |
|
15 |
27 |
Portland |
|
|
|
5 |
2 |
Portland |
|
|
|
5 |
2 |
Tucson |
|
|
|
5 |
12 |
Total-IHS |
3 |
3,429 |
2 |
83 |
443 |
Investment in Nonfederal Physical Property refers to expenses incurred by the Federal Government for the purchase, construction, or major renovation of physical property owned by state, local, or tribal governments: including major additions, alterations and replacements; the purchase of major equipment and the purchase or improvement of other physical assets. Cash grants related to nonfederal physical property programs are included in this decision, but grants for maintenance and operations are not considered investments. In HHS, the only investment in nonfederal physical property relates to former federal properties donated by the Indian Health Service (IHS).
Former federal properties are sites, built with federal funds, over which ownership has been transferred to state, local or Indian tribes through the Indian Self-determination and Education Assistance Act, Public Law 93-638, Section 105(f)(2), as amended. This act allows IHS to donate to an Indian tribe or tribal organization title to any personal or real property. Under this authority, the final regulations governing these transfers were developed and published on June 24, 1996, as 25 CFR Part 900.
| OPDIV/PROGRAM | 2002 | 2001 | 2000 | 1999 | 1998 |
ACF |
|
|
|
|
|
Administration on Developmental Disabilities |
$6 |
$6 |
$8 |
$6 |
$1 |
NIH |
|
|
|
|
|
Research Training and Career Development |
1,248 |
1,118 |
871 |
820 |
660 |
Totals |
$1,254 |
$1,124 |
$879 |
$826 |
$661 |
| OPDIV (1) | 2002 Basic | 2002 Applied | 2002 Develop- Mental | 2002 Total | 2001 Total | 2000 Total | 1999 Total | 1998 Total | Grand Total |
ACF |
|
$ 29 |
|
$ 29 |
$ 32 |
$ 30 |
$ 19 |
$ 13 |
$ 123 |
AHRQ |
|
150 |
|
150 |
127 |
95 |
97 |
139 |
608 |
CDC |
|
533 |
|
533 |
557 |
505 |
433 |
398 |
2,426 |
FDA |
|
23 |
$ 6 |
26 |
26 |
19 |
53 |
153 |
|
HRSA |
|
16 |
|
16 |
16 |
15 |
18 |
44 |
109 |
NIH |
$11,435 |
7,623 |
|
19,058 |
16,007 |
14,690 |
13,580 |
11,038 |
74,373 |
Totals |
$11,435 |
$8,374 |
$ 6 |
$19,815 |
$16,765 |
$15,361 |
$14,166 |
$11,685 |
$77,792 |
(1) ACF's and NIH's FY 2001 amounts have been restated.
AHRQ's FY 2000 amount has been restated.
FDA's FY 1999 amount has been restated.
The many research and development programs in HHS include the following:
FDA has two programs that meet the requirements of research and development investments: Orphan Products Development (OPD) Program and FDA Research Grants Program. While FDA's center components conduct scientific studies, FDA does not consider this type of research as "research and development" because it is used to support FDA's regulatory policy and decision-making processes.
The OPD Program was established by the Orphan Drug Act (PL 97-414, as amended) with the purpose of identifying orphan products and facilitating their development. An orphan product is a drug, biological product, medical device, or medical food that is intended to treat a rare disease or condition (i.e., one with a prevalence of fewer than 200,000 people in the United States.)
The FDA Research Grants Program is a grants program which is listed as No. 93-103 under the Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance, whose purpose is to assist public and non-public institutions and for-profit organizations to establish, expand, and improve research, demonstration, education, and information dissemination activities concerned with a wide variety of FDA areas.
HIV/AIDS prevention, Infectious Diseases, and Environmental and Occupational Health were the primary areas where CDC's research and development was invested.
The NIH Research Program includes all aspects of the medical research continuum, including basic and disease-oriented research, observational and population-based research, behavioral research, and clinical research, including research to understand both health and disease states, to move laboratory findings into medical applications, to assess new treatments or compare different treatment approaches; and health services research. NIH regards the expeditious transfer of the results of its medical research for further development and commercialization of products of immediate benefit to improved health as an important mandate.
ACF, HRSA and AHRQ oversee research and development programs that contribute to a better understanding of how to improve the economic and social well being of families and children so that they lead more healthy and productive lives.
Medicare, the largest health insurance program in the country, has helped fund medical care for the nation's aged and disabled for almost four decades.
The required supplementary stewardship information (RSSI) contained in this section is presented in accordance with the requirements of the Federal Accounting Standards Advisory Board (FASAB). Included are a description of the long?term sustainability and financial condition of the program and a discussion of trends revealed in the data.
RSSI material is generally drawn from the 2002 Annual Report of the Boards of Trustees of the Federal Hospital Insurance and Federal Supplementary Medical Insurance Trust Funds, which represents the official government evaluation of the financial and actuarial status of the Medicare trust funds. Unless otherwise noted, all data are for calendar years, and all projections are based on the Trustees' intermediate set of assumptions.
Printed copies of the Trustees Report may be obtained from CMS's Office of the Actuary (410-786-6386). The report is also available online at http://www.cms.hhs.gov/publications/trusteesreport.
Cashflow in Nominal Dollars
Using nominal dollars for short?term projections paints a reasonably clear picture of expected performance with particular attention on cashflow and trust fund balances. Over longer periods, however, the changing value of the dollar can complicate efforts to compare dollar amounts in different periods and can create severe barriers to interpretation, since projections must be linked to something that the mind can comprehend in today's experience.
For this reason, long?range (75?year) Medicare projections in nominal dollars are seldom used and are not presented here. Instead, nominal?dollar estimates for the HI trust fund are displayed only through the projected date of depletion, currently the year 2030. Estimates for SMI are presented only for the next 10 years, primarily due to the fact that under present law, the SMI trust fund is automatically in financial balance every year.
HI Chart 1 shows the actuarial estimates of HI income, expenditures, and assets for each of the next 30 years, in nominal dollars. Income includes payroll taxes, income from the taxation of Social Security benefits, interest earned on the U.S. Treasury securities held by the trust fund, and other miscellaneous revenue. Expenditures include benefit payments and administrative expenses. The estimates are for the "open group" population-all persons who will participate during the period as either taxpayers or beneficiaries, or both-and consist of payments from, and on behalf of, employees now in the workforce, as well as those who will enter the workforce over the next 30 years. The estimates also include expenditures attributable to these current and future workers, in addition to current beneficiaries.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
Social Insurance
For the Fiscal Year Ended September 30, 2002
Actuarial Projections

As chart 1 shows, under the intermediate assumptions HI expenditures would begin to exceed income including interest in 2022 and income excluding interest in 2016. This situation is due in part to the attainment of Medicare eligibility, starting in 2011, of those born during the 1946?1964 baby boom. It also arises as a result of health cost increases that are expected to continue to grow faster than workers' earnings. Beginning in 2022, the trust fund would start redeeming trust fund assets; in 2030, the assets would be depleted. The projected year of depletion of the trust fund is very sensitive to assumed future economic and other trends. Under less favorable conditions the cash flow could turn negative much earlier and thereby accelerate asset exhaustion.
By law, Medicare trust fund assets are invested in special U.S. Treasury Securities, which earn interest while Treasury uses those cash resources for other Federal purposes. During times of Federal "on-budget" surpluses, this process reduces the Federal debt held by the public. In times of Federal budget deficits, Medicare surpluses reduce the amount that must be borrowed from the public to finance those deficits. The trust fund assets are claims on the Treasury that, when redeemed, will have to be financed by raising taxes, borrowing from the public, or reducing other Federal expenditures. (When the assets are financed by borrowing, the effect is to defer today's costs to later generations who will ultimately repay the funds being borrowed for today's Medicare beneficiaries.) The existence of large trust fund balances, therefore, represents an important obligation of the Government to pay future Medicare benefits but does not necessarily make it easier for the Government to pay those benefits.
SMI
Chart 2 shows the actuarial estimates of SMI income, expenditures, and assets for each of the next 10 years, in nominal dollars. Whereas HI estimates are displayed through the year 2030, SMI estimates cover only the next 10 years, as SMI differs fundamentally from HI in regard to the way it is financed. In particular, SMI financing is not at all based on payroll taxes but instead on monthly premiums and income from the general fund of the U.S. Treasury-both of which are established annually to cover the following year's expenditures. Estimates of SMI income and expenditures, therefore, are virtually the same, as illustrated in chart 2, and so are not shown in nominal dollars separately beyond 10 years.
Income includes monthly premiums paid by, or on behalf of, beneficiaries, transfers from the general fund of the U.S. Treasury, and interest earned on the U.S. Treasury securities held by the trust fund. Chart 2 displays only total income; it does not represent income excluding interest. The difference between the two is not visible graphically since interest is not a significant source of income. Expenditures include benefit payments as well as administrative expenses.
As chart 2 indicates, SMI income is very close to expenditures. As noted earlier, this is due to SMI's financing mechanism. Under present law, SMI is automatically in financial balance every year, regardless of future economic and other conditions.
HI Cashflow as a Percentage of Taxable Payroll
Each year, estimates of the financial and actuarial status of the HI trust fund are prepared for the next 75 years. Because of the difficulty in comparing dollar values for different periods without some type of relative scale, income and expenditure amounts are shown relative to the earnings in covered employment that are taxable under HI (referred to as "taxable payroll").
Chart 3 illustrates income excluding interest and expenditures as a percentage of taxable payroll over the next 75 years. As it was in the 2001 report, the per beneficiary long?range growth in the 2002 report is assumed to be the level of per capita gross domestic product (GDP) growth plus 1 percentage point-reflecting an expectation that the impact of advances in medical technology on health care costs will continue, both in Medicare and in the health sector as a whole.
Since HI payroll tax rates are not scheduled to change in the future under present law, payroll tax income as a percentage of taxable payroll will remain constant at 2.90 percent. Income from taxation of benefits will increase only gradually as a greater proportion of Social Security beneficiaries become subject to such taxation over time. Thus, as chart 3 shows, the income rate is not expected to increase significantly over current levels. On the other hand, expenditures as a percentage of taxable payroll sharply escalate-in part due to health care cost increases that exceed wage growth, but also due to the attainment of Medicare eligibility of those born during the 1946?1964 baby boom.
HI and SMI Cashflow as a Percentage of GDP
Expressing Medicare incurred expenditures as a percentage of the GDP gives a relative measure of the size of the Medicare program compared to the general economy. The GDP represents the total value of goods and services produced in the United States. This measure provides an idea of the relative financial resources that will be necessary to pay for Medicare services.
HI
Chart 4 shows HI income excluding interest and expenditures over the next 75 years expressed as a percentage of GDP. In 2001, the expenditures were $143.4 billion, which was 1.4 percent of GDP. Following slight reductions in 2003 and 2004, this percentage is projected to increase steadily throughout the remainder of the 75-year period.
SMI
As noted earlier, because of the SMI financing mechanism in which income mirrors expenditures, it is not necessary to test for imbalances between income and expenditures. Rather, it is more important to examine the projected rise in expenditures and the implications for beneficiary premiums and Federal general revenue payments.
Chart 5 shows SMI expenditures over the next 75 years expressed as a percentage of GDP. In 2001, SMI expenditures were $101.4 billion, which was 1.0 percent of GDP. After 2005, this percentage is projected to increase steadily, reflecting growth in the volume and intensity of services provided per beneficiary throughout the projection period, together with the effects of the baby boom eligibility for retirement.
In the SMI expenditure projections, as in those for HI, the per beneficiary long?range growth rate is assumed to equal per capita GDP growth plus 1 percentage point. The growth rates are estimated year by year for the next 12 years, reflecting the impact of specific statutory provisions. Expenditure growth for years 13 to 25 is assumed to grade smoothly into the long?range assumptions.
Also shown in chart 5 are SMI general revenue transfers and premium income expressed as a percentage of GDP. Under present law, premiums will cover roughly 25 percent of total expenditures. As indicated, both sources of revenue would increase more rapidly than the GDP over time, to match the faster growth rates for SMI expenditures.
Worker-to-Beneficiary Ratio
HI
Another way to evaluate the long-range outlook of the HI trust fund is to examine the projected number of workers per HI beneficiary. Chart 6 illustrates this ratio over the next 75 years. For the most part, current benefits are paid for by current workers. The retirement of the baby boom generation will therefore be financed by the relatively smaller number of persons born after the baby boom. In 2001, every beneficiary had almost 4.0 workers to pay for his or her benefit. In 2030, however, after the last baby boomer turns 65, there will be only about 2.4 workers per beneficiary. The projected ratio continues to decline until there are just 2.0 workers per beneficiary in 2076.
Actuarial Present Values
Projected future expenditures can be summarized by computing an "actuarial present value." This value represents the lump?sum amount that, if invested today in trust fund securities, would be just sufficient to pay each year's expenditures over the next 75 years, with the fund being drawn down to zero at the end of the period. Similarly, future revenues (excluding interest) can be summarized as a single, equivalent amount as of the current year.
Actuarial present values are calculated by discounting the future annual amounts of non?interest income and expenditures at the assumed rates of interest credited to the HI and SMI trust funds. Present values are computed as of the beginning of the 75?year projection period for three different groups of participants: current workers and other individuals who have not yet attained eligibility age; current beneficiaries who have attained eligibility age; and new entrants, or those who are expected to become participants in the future.
Table 1 sets forth, for each of these three groups, the actuarial present values of all future HI and SMI expenditures and all future non?interest income for the next 75 years. Also shown is the net present value of cashflow, which is calculated by subtracting the actuarial present value of future expenditures from the actuarial present value of future income.
| Table 1-Actuarial Present Values of Hospital Insurance and Supplementary Medical InsuranceRevenues and Expenditures:75-year Projection as of January 1, 2002 (In billions) |
||||||
| HI | SMI | |||||
| 2002 | 2001 | 2000 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000 | |
Actuarial present value1 of estimated future income (excluding interest) received from or on behalf of: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Current participants who, at start of projection period: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Have not yet attained eligibility age (ages 15-64) |
$4,408 |
$4,136 |
$3,757 |
$7,423 |
$7,378 |
$6,109 |
Have attained eligibility age (age 65 and over) |
125 |
113 |
97 |
1,008 |
1,032 |
934 |
Those expected to become participants (under age 15) |
3,753 |
3,507 |
3,179 |
2,402 |
2,370 |
1,616 |
All current and future participants |
8,286 |
7,757 |
7,033 |
10,833 |
10,780 |
8,659 |
Actuarial present value1 of estimated future expenditures4 paid to or on behalf of: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Current participants who, at start of projection period: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Have not yet attained eligibility age (ages 15-64) |
9,195 |
8,568 |
6,702 |
7,463 |
7,415 |
6,094 |
Have attained eligibility age (age 65 and over) |
1,747 |
1,693 |
1,681 |
1,132 |
1,159 |
1,051 |
Those expected to become participants (under age 15) |
2,470 |
2,225 |
1,349 |
2,238 |
2,206 |
1,514 |
All current and future participants |
13,412 |
12,487 |
9,732 |
10,833 |
10,780 |
8,659 |
Actuarial present value of estimated future income (excluding interest) less expenditures |
-5,126 |
-4,730 |
-2,700 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
Trust fund assets at start of period |
209 |
177 |
141 |
41 |
44 |
45 |
Assets at start of period plus actuarial present value of estimated future income (excluding interest) less expenditures |
-4,917 |
-4,553 |
-2,558 |
41 |
44 |
45 |
Present values are computed on the basis of the intermediate set of economic and demographic assumptions specified in the Report of the Boards of Trustees for the year shown and over the 75-year projection period beginning January 1 of that year |
||||||
SMI income includes premiums paid by beneficiaries and general revenue contributions made on behalf of beneficiaries. See footnote 3 on page 40 concerning treatment of SMI general revenues in the consolidated financial statement of the U.S. Government. |
||||||
Current participants are the "closed group" of individuals age 15 and over at the start of the period. The projection period for these current participants would theoretically cover all of their working and retirement years, a period that could be greater than 75 years in some instances. As a practical matter, the present values of future income and expenditures from/for current participants beyond 75 years are not material. The projection period for new entrants covers the next 75 years. |
||||||
Expenditures include benefit payments and administrative expenses. |
||||||
Note: Totals do not necessarily equal the sums of rounded components. |
||||||
As shown in table 1, the HI trust fund has an actuarial deficit of more than $4.9 trillion over the 75-year projection period, as compared to more than $4.5 trillion in the 2001 financial report. SMI, on the other hand, does not have similar problems because it is automatically in financial balance every year due to its financing mechanism.
The existence of a large actuarial deficit for the HI trust fund indicates that, under reasonable assumptions as to economic, demographic, and health cost trends for the future, HI income is expected to fall substantially short of expenditures in the long range. Although the deficits are not anticipated in the immediate future, as indicated by the preceding cashflow projections, they nonetheless pose a serious financial problem for the HI trust fund.
It is important to note that no liability has been recognized on the balance sheet for future payments to be made to current and future program participants beyond the existing "incurred but not reported" Medicare claim amounts as of September 30, 2002. This is because Medicare is accounted for as a social insurance program rather than a pension program. Accounting for a social insurance program recognizes the expense of benefits when they are actually paid, or are due to be paid, because benefit payments are primarily nonexchange transactions and, unlike employer-sponsored pension benefits for employees, are not considered deferred compensation. Accrual accounting for a pension program, by contrast, recognizes retirement benefit expenses as they are earned so that the full actuarial present value of the worker's expected retirement benefits has been recognized by the time the worker retires.
Actuarial Assumptions and Sensitivity Analysis
In order to make projections regarding the future financial status of the HI and SMI trust funds, various assumptions have to be made. First and foremost, the estimates presented here are based on the assumption that the trust funds will continue under present law. In addition, the estimates depend on many economic and demographic assumptions, including changes in wages and the consumer price index (CPI), fertility rates, immigration rates, and interest rates. In most cases, these assumptions vary from year to year during the first 5 to 30 years before reaching their ultimate values for the remainder of the 75?year projection period.
Table 2 shows some of the underlying assumptions used in the projections of Medicare spending displayed in this section. Further details on these assumptions are available in the OASDI and Medicare Trustees Reports for 2002. In practice, a number of specific assumptions are made for each of the different types of service provided by the Medicare program (for example, hospital care and physician services). These assumptions include changes in the utilization, volume, and intensity of each type of service. The per beneficiary cost increases displayed in table 2 reflect the overall impact of these more detailed assumptions.
| Table 2-Medicare Assumptions | |||||||||
|
|
|
|
Annual percentage change in: |
|
||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Per beneficiary cost |
|
|
|
Fertility rate |
Net immigration |
Real-wage differential |
Wages |
CPI |
Real GDP |
HI |
SMI |
Real- interest rate |
2002 |
2.13 |
900,000 |
1.8 |
3.1 |
1.3 |
0.7 |
3.5 |
4.2 |
3.6 |
2005 |
2.10 |
900,000 |
1.2 |
4.1 |
2.9 |
3.2 |
4.5 |
5.2 |
3.5 |
2010 |
2.07 |
900,000 |
1.0 |
4.1 |
3.0 |
2.2 |
4.4 |
5.5 |
3.0 |
2020 |
1.99 |
900,000 |
1.1 |
4.1 |
3.0 |
1.8 |
4.4 |
5.2 |
3.0 |
2030 |
1.95 |
900,000 |
1.1 |
4.1 |
3.0 |
1.8 |
5.9 |
5.6 |
3.0 |
2040 |
1.95 |
900,000 |
1.1 |
4.1 |
3.0 |
1.8 |
6.1 |
5.3 |
3.0 |
2050 |
1.95 |
900,000 |
1.1 |
4.1 |
3.0 |
1.7 |
5.2 |
4.9 |
3.0 |
2060 |
1.95 |
900,000 |
1.1 |
4.1 |
3.0 |
1.7 |
5.3 |
5.4 |
3.0 |
2070 |
1.95 |
900,000 |
1.1 |
4.1 |
3.0 |
1.7 |
5.5 |
5.2 |
3.0 |
2076 |
1.95 |
900,000 |
1.1 |
4.1 |
3.0 |
1.6 |
5.4 |
5.1 |
3.0 |
Average number of children per woman. |
|||||||||
Difference between percentage increases in wages and the CPI. |
|||||||||
See text for nature of this assumption. |
|||||||||
Average rate of interest earned on new trust fund securities, above and beyond rate of inflation. |
|||||||||
Estimates made in prior years have sometimes changed substantially because of revisions to the assumptions, which are due either to changed conditions or to more recent experience. Furthermore, it is important to recognize that actual conditions are very likely to differ from the projections presented here, since the future cannot be anticipated with certainty. In order to illustrate the magnitude of the sensitivity of the long?range projections, six of the key assumptions were varied individually to determine the impact on the HI actuarial present values and net cashflows. The assumptions varied are the fertility rate, net immigration, real?wage differential, CPI, real-interest rate, and health care cost factors.
For this analysis, the intermediate economic and demographic assumptions in the 2002 Annual Report of the Boards of Trustees of the Federal Hospital Insurance and Federal Supplementary Medical Insurance Trust Funds are used as the reference point. Each selected assumption is varied individually to produce three scenarios. All present values are calculated as of January 1, 2002 and are based on estimates of income and expenditures during the 75?year projection period.
Charts 7 through 12 show the net annual HI cashflow in nominal dollars and the present value of this net cashflow for each assumption varied. In most instances, the charts depicting the estimated net cashflow indicate that, after increasing in the early years, net cashflow decreases steadily through 2030 under all three scenarios displayed.
On the present value charts, the same pattern is evident, though the magnitudes are lower because of the discounting process used for computing present values.
Fertility Rate
| Table 3-Present Value of Estimated HI Income Less Expenditures under Various Fertility Rate Assumptions | |||
Ultimate fertility rate |
1.7 |
1.95 |
2.2 |
Income minus expenditures (in billions) |
-$5,266 |
-$5,126 |
-$4,989 |
The total fertility rate for any year is the average number of children who would be born to a woman in her lifetime if she were to experience the birth rates by age observed in, or assumed for, the selected year and if she were to survive the entire childbearing period. |
|||
Table 3 demonstrates that if the assumed ultimate fertility rate is decreased from 1.95 to 1.7, the projected deficit of income over expenditures increases from $5,126 billion to $5,266 billion. On the other hand, if the ultimate fertility rate is increased from 1.95 to 2.2 children per woman, the deficit decreases to $4,989 billion.
Charts 7 and 7A show projections of the net cashflow under the three alternative fertility rate assumptions presented in table 3.
As charts 7 and 7A indicate, the fertility rate assumption has only a negligible impact on projected HI cashflows over the next 30 years. This is because higher fertility in the first year does not affect the labor force until roughly 20 years have passed (increasing HI payroll taxes slightly) and has virtually no impact on the number of beneficiaries within this period. Over the full 75?year period, the changes are somewhat greater, as illustrated by the present values in table 3.
Net Immigration
Table 4 shows the net present value of cashflow during the 75?year projection period under three alternative net immigration assumptions: 655,000 persons, 900,000 persons, and 1,210,000 persons per year.
| Table 4-Present Value of Estimated HI Income Less Expenditures under Various Net Immigration Assumptions | |||
Ultimate net immigration |
655,000 |
900,000 |
1,210,000 |
Income minus expenditures (in billions) |
-$5,094 |
-$5,126 |
-$5,156 |
Table 4 demonstrates that if the ultimate net immigration assumption is decreased from 900,000 to 655,000 persons, the deficit of income over expenditures decreases from $5,126 billion to $5,094 billion. On the other hand, if the ultimate net immigration assumption is increased from 900,000 to 1,210,000 persons, the deficit increases to $5,156 billion.
Charts 8 and 8A show projections of the net cashflow under the three alternative net immigration assumptions presented in table 4.
As charts 8 and 8A indicate, this assumption has an impact on projected HI cashflow starting almost immediately. Because immigration tends to occur among younger individuals, the number of covered workers is affected immediately, while the number of beneficiaries is affected much less quickly. Nonetheless, variations in net immigration result in fairly small differences in cashflow.
Real-Wage Differential
Table 5 shows the net present value of cashflow during the 75?year projection period under three alternative ultimate real?wage differential assumptions: 0.6, 1.1, and 1.6 percentage points. In each case, the CPI is assumed to be 3.0 percent, yielding ultimate percentage increases in average annual wages in covered employment of 3.6, 4.1, and 4.6 percent, respectively.
| Table 5-Present Value of Estimated HI Income Less Expenditures under Various Real-Wage Assumptions | |||
|
|||
Ultimate percentage increase in wages - CPI |
3.6 - 3.0 |
4.1 - 3.0 |
4.6 - 3.0 |
Ultimate percentage increase in real-wage differential |
0.6 |
1.1 |
1.6 |
Income minus expenditures (in billions) |
-$5,361 |
-$5,126 |
-$4,812 |
Table 5 demonstrates that if the ultimate real?wage differential assumption is decreased from 1.1 percentage points to 0.6 percentage point, the deficit of income over expenditures increases from $5,126 billion to $5,361 billion. On the other hand, if the ultimate real?wage differential assumption is increased from 1.1 percentage points to 1.6 percentage points, the deficit decreases to $4,812 billion.
Charts 9 and 9A show projections of the net cashflow under the three alternative real-wage differential assumptions presented in table 5.
As charts 9 and 9A indicate, this assumption has a fairly large impact on projected HI cashflow very early in the projection period. Higher real?wage differential assumptions immediately increase both HI expenditures for health care and wages for all workers. Though there is a full effect on wages and payroll taxes, the effect on benefits is only partial, since not all health care costs are wage?related.
Consumer Price Index
Table 6 shows the net present value of cashflow during the 75-year projection period under three alternative ultimate CPI rate-of-increase assumptions: 2.0, 3.0, and 4.0 percent. In each case, the ultimate real?wage differential is assumed to be 1.1 percent, yielding ultimate percentage increases in average annual wages in covered employment of 3.1, 4.1, and 5.1 percent, respectively.
| Table 6-Present Value of Estimated HI Income Less Expenditures under Various CPI-Increase Assumptions | |||
Ultimate percentage increase in wages - CPI |
3.1 - 2.0 |
4.1 - 3.0 |
5.1 - 4.0 |
Income minus expenditures (in billions) |
-$5,149 |
-$5,126 |
-$5,148 |
Table 6 demonstrates that if the ultimate CPI increase assumption is decreased from 3.0 percent to 2.0 percent, the deficit of income over expenditures increases from $5,126 billion to $5,149 billion. Furthermore, if the ultimate CPI increase assumption is increased from 3.0 percent to 4.0 percent, the deficit increases to $5,148 billion.
Charts 10 and 10A show projections of the net cashflow under the three alternative CPI rate-of-increase assumptions presented in table 6.
As charts 10 and 10A indicate, this assumption has a large impact on projected HI cashflow in nominal dollars but only a negligible impact when the cashflow is expressed as present values. The relative insensitivity of the projected present values of HI cashflow to different levels of general inflation occurs because inflation tends to affect both income and costs equally. In nominal dollars, however, a given deficit "looks bigger" under high?inflation conditions but is not significantly different when it is expressed as a present value or relative to taxable payroll. This sensitivity test serves as a useful example of the limitations of nominal?dollar projections over long periods.
Real-Interest Rate
Table 7 shows the net present value of cashflow during the 75?year projection period under three alternative ultimate real?interest assumptions: 2.2, 3.0, and 3.7 percent. In each case, the ultimate annual increase in the CPI is assumed to be 3.0 percent, resulting in ultimate annual yields of 5.2, 6.0, and 6.7 percent, respectively.
| Present Value of Estimated HI Income Less Expenditures under Various Real-Interest Assumptions | |||
Ultimate real-interest rate |
2.2 percent |
3.0 percent |
3.7 percent |
Income minus expenditures (in billions) |
-$7,892 |
-$5,126 |
-$3,812 |
Table 7 demonstrates that if the ultimate real?interest rate percentage is decreased from 3.0 percent to 2.2 percent, the deficit of income over expenditures increases from $5,126 billion to $7,892 billion. On the other hand, if the ultimate real?interest rate assumption is increased from 3.0 percent to 3.7 percent, the deficit decreases to $3,812 billion.
Charts 11 and 11A show projections of the net cashflow under the three alternative real?interest assumptions presented in table 7.
As shown in charts 11 and 11A, the present values of the net cashflow are more sensitive to the interest assumption than is the nominal net cashflow. This is not an indication of the actual role that interest plays in HI financing. In actuality, interest finances very little of the cost of the HI trust fund because, under the intermediate assumptions, the fund is projected to be relatively low and exhausted by 2030. These results illustrate the substantial sensitivity of present value measures to different interest rate assumptions. With higher assumed interest, the very large deficits in the more distant future are discounted more heavily (that is, are given less weight), and the overall net present value is smaller.
Health Care Cost Factors
Table 8 shows the net present value of cashflow during the 75?year projection period under three alternative assumptions of the annual growth rate in the aggregate cost of providing covered health care services to beneficiaries. These assumptions are that the ultimate annual growth rate in such costs, relative to taxable payroll, will be 1 percent slower than the intermediate assumptions, the same as the intermediate assumptions, and 1 percent faster than the intermediate assumptions. In each case, the taxable payroll will be the same as that which was assumed for the intermediate assumptions
| Table 8-Present Value of Estimated HI Income Less Expenditures under Various Health Care Cost Growth Rate Assumptions | |||
Annual cost/payroll relative growth rate |
-1 percentage point |
Intermediate assumptions |
+1 percentage point |
Income minus expenditures (in billions) |
-$906 |
-$5,126 |
-$12,047 |
Table 8 demonstrates that if the ultimate growth rate assumption is 1 percentage point lower than the intermediate assumptions, the deficit of income over expenditures decreases from $5,126 billion to $906 billion. On the other hand, if the ultimate growth rate assumption is 1 percentage point higher than the intermediate assumptions, the deficit increases substantially to $12,047 billion.
Charts 12 and 12A show projections of the net cashflow under the three alternative annual growth rate assumptions presented in table 8.
This assumption has a dramatic impact on projected HI cashflow. The assumptions analyzed thus far have affected HI income and costs simultaneously. However, several factors, such as the utilization of services by beneficiaries or the relative complexity of services provided, can affect costs without affecting tax income. As charts 12 and 12A indicate, the financial status of the HI trust fund is extremely sensitive to the relative growth rates for health care service costs versus taxable payroll.
Trust Fund Finances and Sustainability
HI
The HI trust fund is substantially out of financial balance in the long range. Under the Medicare Trustees' intermediate assumptions, income is projected to continue to moderately exceed expenditures for the next 20 years but to fall short by steadily increasing amounts in 2022 and later. These shortfalls can be met by redeeming trust fund assets, but only until 2030.
To bring the HI trust fund into actuarial balance over the next 75 years under the intermediate assumptions, either outlays would have to be reduced by 38 percent or income increased by 60 percent (or some combination of the two) throughout the 75?year period. These substantial changes in income and/or outlays are needed in part as a result of the impending retirement of the baby boom generation.
The projections presented here indicate that without additional legislation, the fund would be exhausted in the future-initially producing payment delays, but very quickly leading to a curtailment of health care services to beneficiaries.
SMI
The financing established for the SMI trust fund for calendar year 2002 is estimated to be sufficient to cover expenditures for that year and to preserve an adequate contingency reserve in the fund. Moreover, for all future years, trust fund income is projected to equal expenditures-but only because beneficiary premiums and government general revenue contributions are set to meet expected costs each year.
The SMI trust fund's automatic financing provisions prevent crises such as those faced in recent years by the HI trust fund, the assets of which were projected to be exhausted in the near future. As a result, there has been substantially less attention directed toward the financial status of the SMI trust fund than to the HI trust fund-even though SMI expenditures have increased faster than HI expenditures in most years and are expected to continue to do so for a number of years in the future.
SMI costs have generally grown faster than the GDP, and this trend is expected to continue under present law. The projected increases are initially attributable in part to assumed continuing growth in the volume and intensity of services provided per beneficiary. Starting in 2011, the attainment of Medicare eligibility of the post?World War II baby boom generation will also have a major influence on the growth in SMI costs. This growth in SMI expenditures relative to GDP is a matter of great concern.
Medicare Overall
The projections shown in this section continue to demonstrate the need for the Administration and the Congress to address the financial challenges facing Medicare-both the remaining financial imbalance facing the HI trust fund and the continuing problem of rapid growth in SMI expenditures. In their 2002 annual report to Congress, the Medicare Boards of Trustees emphasize the seriousness of these concerns and urge the nation's policy makers to take "effective and decisive action…to build upon the strong steps taken in recent reforms." They also state: "Consideration of further reforms should occur in the relatively near future."